Promise connection, engineer its opposite, three acts from Zuckerberg

The man who burned $68.5 billion on a virtual world has a new promise. He now wants to "empower" you with an AI that sees everything you see.

This is Zuckerberg's recurring pattern: promise connection, engineer its opposite.

Here are the three acts in this cycle:

—

Act I: Connect the World

The Public Promise (2017): To "bring the world closer together," evolving Facebook's mission to a global community¹.

↳ The Business Reality: An algorithm optimized for one metric - engagement - creating addiction loops to maximize revenue.

→ The Human Cost: An MIT/Tel Aviv 2022 study on college campuses linked Facebook's arrival to a 7% increase in severe depression and a 20% increase in anxiety disorders².

—

Act II: Total Immersion

The Public Promise (2021): To build the Metaverse, a digital utopia solving distance with a "feeling of presence"³.

↳ The Business Reality: A convenient coincidence? Weeks after the Haugen scandal revealed Meta knew its platforms harmed teens, the company announced its $68B Metaverse escape route⁴.

→ The Human Cost: The "presence" promise created a ghost town. Internal data revealed catastrophic retention: weekly Horizon Worlds users plummeted to 11%⁵, while over 50% of Quest headsets were abandoned in six months⁶. A Meta VP's memo asked: "If we don't love it, how can we expect our users to love it?"⁷

—

Act III (The Future): Personal AI SuperintelligenceThe Public Promise (2025): A personal superintelligence for an "exciting new era of individual empowerment"⁸.

↳ The Business Reality: The perfection of the original model: an AI that "knows us deeply" through glasses that see and hear all⁸.

→ The Projected Human Cost: If you won't go to the Metaverse, it will come to you. This threatens a total colonization of experience, a model where your autonomy is the final territory to mine.

—

The pattern is clear: public humanism as a cover for a business model of resource extraction. Monetize the value, let society take care of the damages.

This focus is embodied by a t-shirt he wore during his 2024 personal rebrand:

"Aut Zuck aut nihil." Either Zuck or nothing.

It's a riff on Cesare Borgia's motto, "Aut Caesar aut nihil." Borgia's strategy was infamous: a patient operation of pretended peace, followed by the strangulation of his rivals⁹.

A perfect metaphor for the strategy we're witnessing: a grand promise of empowerment, followed by the quiet strangulation of human autonomy.

Aut Zuck aut nihil.

Perhaps humanity should choose nihil.

—

Critique is the first step. The second is building the alternative. My work is helping teams implement Responsible AI-technology that makes them more capable, not more captive.

—

Sources in the comments